Both Callbacks and promises are used to handle asynchronous operations in JavaScript, but they differ significantly in readability and maintainability. 1. Callbacks are functions passed as parameters, suitable for simple or old environments, but when nested for a long time, it is easy to cause "callback hell". 2. Promise improves code clarity and error handling capabilities through .then() and .catch() chain calls, suitable for complex logic and modern JS features. 3. Use suggestions: Select callbacks for small scripts or old browsers; select Promise when complex asynchronous logic or when using async/await, and convert callbacks to Promise through encapsulation to improve compatibility.

If you're working with asynchronous code in JavaScript, you've probably come across both callbacks and promises. They do similar jobs — letting you handle async operations — but they work very differently. Promises are generally easier to read and manage, especially as your code grows. But to choose the right one for your situation, it's good to understand how each works in practice.

What Are Callbacks and How Do They Work?

A callback is just a function passed as an argument to another function. It gets called later, usually after some async task finishes — like reading a file or making an API request.

Here's a simple example:

 function fetchData(callback) {
  setTimeout(() => {
    callback('Data received');
  }, 1000);
}

fetchData((data) => {
  console.log(data); // Logs "Data received" after 1 second
});

This works fine when you have one or two async steps, but things get messy fast if you have more. You end up with what's often called callback hell — nested callbacks that are hard to follow and debug.

Some pros of callbacks:

• Simple to understand at a basic level
• Supported everywhere (even in old browsers)

But the downsides:

• Harder to scale and maintain
• Error handling can be inconsistent

How Promises Improve on Callbacks

Promises were introduced to make async code cleaner and more predictable. A promise represents a value that may be available now, later, or never. You can chain .then() for success and .catch() for errors.

Here's the same example using a promise:

 function fetchData() {
  return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
    setTimeout(() => {
      resolve('Data received');
    }, 1000);
  });
}

fetchData()
  .then(data => console.log(data))
  .catch(error => console.error(error));

Promises help avoid deep nesting by allowing chaining:

 fetchData()
  .then(data => process(data))
  .then(result => save(result))
  .catch(err => handleError(err));

Benefits of promises:

• Better readability with .then() and .catch()
• Easier error handling with centralized .catch()
• Support for multiple async steps without deep nesting

Still, there are cases where callbacks are used — like in older APIs or performance-sensitive situations where overhead matters.

When to Use Each One

Most modern JavaScript uses promises — especially with async/await , which makes them even cleaner. But there are still times when callbacks might be better suited:

Use callbacks when:

• You're dealing with a small script or quick prototype
• The environment doesn't support promises (like very old browsers)
• You're working with a library or API that uses callbacks by design

Use promises when:

• Your app has complex async logic
• You want cleaner error handling
• You're using newer JS features like async/await

Also keep in mind: many older callback-based functions can be wrapped into promises easily, so you can use them in modern codebases.

A Few Practical Tips

If you're moving from callbacks to promises, here are a few tips:

• Wrap callback-style functions in a promise to integrate smoothly
• Always add a .catch() at the end of your promise chain to avoid unhandled rejections
• Prefer async/await for long chains — it reads more like synchronous code

One thing people often forget is that promises execute immediately when created. So if you want to delay execution, wrap the promise in a function.

And remember: not all async functions need to return promises. If something is truly synchronous, don't force a promise — it'll just complicate things unnecessarily.

That's the core of the difference between callbacks and promises. Both can work depending on the context, but for most modern applications, promises offer a much smoother experience.

The above is the detailed content of Comparing Javascript Promises and Callbacks for Asynchronous Code. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!