Edward Snowden Reignites Solana Centralization Debate, Advocates Respond
Oct 04, 2024 am 01:10 AMRenowned Bitcoin pundit Edward Snowden boldly asserts that Solana “is centralized,” reigniting debates about the network's design.
Renowned Bitcoin pundit Edward Snowden has boldly asserted that Solana “is centralized,” reigniting debates about the network's design. Speaking virtually at the Singapore Token 2049 conference, Snowden responded to a question on how blockchain networks could be designed from a “first principles” perspective to remain secure. He pointed to Bitcoin's design as a system built to withstand state intervention, in contrast to Solana, which he argued is at risk due to centralization. Snowden warned that Solana's structure could easily fall under state control if governments chose to intervene. His comments echoed previous critiques regarding Solana's governance model. Crypto advocates have long expressed concerns about Solana's centralization, with Snowden's remarks amplifying the discussion. According to Snowden, if a network is not designed to resist government intervention from the ground up, it risks losing autonomy, as seen with platforms like Telegram.
Other Centralization ConcernsThe issue of centralization within Solana has been a focal point for critics for a while now. Stake with Pride, a well-known Cardano supporter, recently highlighted data that suggested over 73% of Solana validators comply with Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML) requirements. This led to further questions about the extent of decentralization in Solana's network.
Furthermore, Stake with Pride pointed out that Solana's validator program, driven by its Foundation, automatically subsidizes validators who follow predefined rules. This has led to comparisons between Solana's structure and traditional banking systems, further fueling concerns about its centralization.
Solana Supporters’ DefenceIn response to Snowden's remarks, Mert Mumtaz, co-founder of Helius Labs and a strong advocate for Solana, challenged centralization claims. Mumtaz emphasized the need for factual evidence, pointing out that Snowden did not provide specific data to support his statements that “Solana is centralized.” He argued that Solana's network, with thousands of geographically distributed nodes across different jurisdictions, makes it resilient to centralized control. Mumtaz further noted that Solana's decentralization is evolving, with multiple clients, such as Frankendancer, now live on the mainnet, ensuring that the system has no single point of failure.
Meanwhile, despite the ongoing debate, Solana continues to gain attention for its potential. Analysts like Jelle have recently expressed optimism about the network, suggesting it may soon break out of its consolidation phase to an all-time high despite the broader crypto market's struggles.
The above is the detailed content of Edward Snowden Reignites Solana Centralization Debate, Advocates Respond. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Hot AI Tools

Undress AI Tool
Undress images for free

Undresser.AI Undress
AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover
Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Clothoff.io
AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap
Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Article

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1
Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version
Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1
Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6
Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version
God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

Hot Topics

American business intelligence and software firm MicroStrategy Inc. has announced plans to offer the public up to $1.75 billion of its Convertible Senior Notes.

Many ETF issuers are scrambling to apply for SolanaETF, but BlackRock is still holding back? This article will interpret this phenomenon. SolanaETF application boom The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has accepted SolanaETF applications submitted by several institutions, including Bitwise, 21Shares, VanEck, CanaryCapital and Grayscale. Bloomberg predicts that the probability of Solana spot ETF being approved by the end of the year is as high as 70%, which is closely related to the Trump administration's friendly attitude towards cryptocurrencies. The establishment of Franklin's "Franklin SolanaTrust" also implies its potential application for SolanaETF. However, Sol

Glauber Contessoto, also known as "Dogecoin millionaire," expressed bullish sentiments on Ethereum ETH/USD, predicting a parabolic rise for the second-largest cryptocurrency.

Solana (SOL) ETF application: In-depth analysis and future prospects In the near future, there is a surge in crypto ETF applications, which is closely related to the SEC's increasingly friendly attitude towards cryptocurrencies and its clear approval rules. As a mainstream cryptocurrency, Solana (SOL)'s ETF application progress has attracted much attention. This article will conduct in-depth discussion on the current status, impact and future prospects of SOLETF applications. Current status of SOLETF application. Several institutions have submitted SOL spot ETF applications, among which Grayscale is particularly eye-catching. It plans to convert Solana Trust Fund into spot ETF, which will further expand its influence in the digital asset market. If approved, the ETF will be listed on the New York Stock Exchange under the code

Solana's recent price decline may be related to the potential Binance listing speculation of PiCoin (PI). Binance's poll showed that 86% of participants supported the listing of PI coins, which could attract a large amount of capital to flow into PI, causing some Solana investors to turn to PI. Solana's price plummeted: Will PI coins replace SOL and become the first choice for investors? Solana (SOL) prices have fallen sharply recently, falling 16% last week and 37% last month. Loss of key support levels has heightened investor concerns. While the overall crypto market downturn is partly responsible, the panic selling of traders has exacerbated the decline. Solana network activity has dropped significantly, with transaction volume plummeting from $1.99 billion in November 2024

SolanaETF: Will it be approved this year? What impact will it have on the market? After Bitcoin and Ethereum spot ETFs were approved, the market's attention turned to the next potential ETF target: Solana. Several companies have submitted SolanaETF applications, triggering heated discussions in the market about the possibility that SOL spot ETF will be approved this year. Latest progress of SolanaETF Recently, VolatilityShares' two Solana futures ETFs have been included in the US Securities Centralized Custody and Settlement Company (DTCC) list, indicating that the SolanaETF ecosystem has entered a critical stage and has also increased the expectation of SOL spot ETF approval. DTCC plays a central role in global financial markets, and its list means these

MicroStrategy intends to use the net proceeds to acquire additional Bitcoin and for general corporate purposes. The offering will be available to institutional investors and certain non-US buyers.

The crypto market today has been showcasing an upbeat momentum since Asian trading hours, with the market cap climbing by 1.74% to $3.08 Trillion.