Session-based authentication is better for server-rendered web apps, while JWT suits APIs and SPAs. Sessions store data server-side, are easy to use in PHP, and allow instant revocation, but require shared storage when scaling. JWTs are stateless, scalable, and work well across domains, but lack built-in revocation and need careful handling to prevent security risks. Choose sessions for traditional apps with PHP’s built-in support or JWT for distributed systems, APIs, or mobile backends.

When it comes to handling user authentication in PHP applications, two commonly used approaches are JWT (JSON Web Tokens) and session-based authentication. While both aim to verify who the user is, they work differently under the hood and have distinct pros and cons depending on your use case.

Here’s a breakdown of how they differ and when you might choose one over the other.

How Session-Based Authentication Works

In a traditional session-based setup, when a user logs in, the server creates a session — usually a small piece of data stored on the server — and sends a session ID back to the client, often as a cookie.

• The session ID is unique to that user and is used to look up their session data on subsequent requests.
• This means the server has to keep track of all active sessions, typically in files or a database.
• Since cookies are involved by default, this method works well for browser-based apps and is easy to implement in PHP with built-in functions like session_start().

One thing to note: because sessions are stored server-side, scaling can become an issue if you're running multiple servers or using load balancers. You’ll need shared storage like Redis or a database to manage sessions across instances.

What JWT Authentication Looks Like

JWT, or JSON Web Token, is a stateless authentication mechanism. Instead of storing session data on the server, the server signs a token containing user information and sends it back to the client.

• That token is then sent with every request, usually in the Authorization header.
• The server doesn’t store anything locally — it just verifies the signature and reads the data from the token.
• Tokens can be signed using algorithms like HMAC or RSA, making them tamper-proof.

This makes JWT great for APIs and mobile apps where keeping state isn't practical. It also scales better since there's no need to share session data between servers.

But it does come with trade-offs — for example, revoking a token before it expires is tricky unless you build in extra logic like a blacklist.

Main Differences Between JWT and Sessions

There are several key differences that affect how each method performs and fits into different types of applications:

• Stateful vs Stateless:
  Sessions are stateful (server keeps track), while JWTs are stateless (no server-side storage needed).

• Scalability:
  JWTs scale more easily across distributed systems. Sessions require shared storage when used in multi-server setups.

• Security Considerations:
  Sessions are generally safer from token theft if handled correctly (e.g., secure cookies with HttpOnly flag). JWTs must be properly protected against interception and replay attacks.

• Payload Size and Overhead:
  JWTs carry more data per request (in headers), which can add overhead. Sessions only send a small session ID.

• Revocation and Expiry:
  Sessions can be destroyed instantly. JWT tokens are harder to revoke before expiry without additional infrastructure.

Which One Should You Use in PHP?

If you're building a standard web app with login forms and pages rendered on the server side, session-based authentication is straightforward and well-supported in PHP out of the box.

For APIs, SPAs (Single Page Apps), or microservices architectures, JWT might be a better fit due to its stateless nature and cross-domain flexibility.

Also consider your team's familiarity and existing tooling. If you’re already using something like Laravel, it has solid support for both via Passport/Sanctum (for JWT/OAuth) and session drivers.

In short, neither JWT nor session-based authentication is universally better — it depends on what your app needs. Both can be implemented securely and efficiently in PHP, but they solve different problems and come with different trade-offs.

The above is the detailed content of What are the differences between JWT and Session-based authentication in PHP?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!